After Donald Trump Said It, How News Outlets Handled It

news image

Mr. Acosta, on CNN, the first network to broadcast the term without asterisks, said the word several times on-air, even as Mr. Blitzer opted for the more chaste “S-hole.”

It is exceedingly rare for the country’s biggest news organizations to publish a quote that includes an expletive; usually, they employ a censored or blanked-out version. On Thursday’s network evening newscasts, NBC News was the only organization that quoted Mr. Trump in full. Anchors at ABC and CBS used the word “blank” instead.

But several media executives said on Thursday that the news value of Mr. Trump’s remarks, which the White House did not dispute, was undeniable.

Interactive Graphic

A Year Later, Trump Is Less Popular Across Voting Blocs. See by How Much.

President Trump’s approval rating fell across many demographic groups over his first year in office, including among those seen as important to his base.



OPEN Interactive Graphic


“It would be futile to mask the word when the language itself, in reference to Haiti and African countries, was so extraordinary,” said The A.P.’s vice president for standards, John Daniszewski.

Phil Corbett, the associate managing editor for standards at The New York Times, said in an email: “It seemed pretty clear to all of us that we should quote the language directly, not paraphrase it. We wanted to be sure readers would fully understand what the story was about.”

The Times, unlike some papers, omitted the obscenity from its headline and push alert, using the term “vulgar language” instead. “We are still inclined to be somewhat restrained — for instance, by avoiding the actual vulgarities in headlines,” Mr. Corbett said.

Mr. Trump has tested these standards in the past. The word “pussy” was published by many major outlets during the 2016 presidential race after footage emerged of Mr. Trump boasting, in vulgar terms, that he had grabbed women by their genitals.

At a rally in September, carried live by some networks, Mr. Trump used the term “son of a bitch” to refer to football players who kneel during the national anthem.

Past administrations also generated moments of vulgarity, including former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr., who used a profanity in marveling at the passage of the Affordable Care Act, and former President George W. Bush, who was caught on a live microphone using an expletive when referring to a Times reporter.

But Mr. Trump’s remarks — and the speed with which they have entered the public domain — are a new test for media outlets, especially when the comments appear to reveal privately held beliefs of the commander in chief. In this case, Mr. Trump’s comment, in the context of a discussion on immigration, was widely seen as evidence of prejudice.

“Times and levels of White House discourse, and what the public will tolerate, have flipped,” Frank Sesno, a former CNN Washington bureau chief, said on Thursday.

He added, “Right along with the rest of our culture.”

Continue reading the main story

Read More